Murmurations uses a near-immediate and transparent review process as shown in the figure below and described in this video.  After an artifact is submitted, passes the format and fitness standards for the journal, and a minimum of two Reflectors are engaged, the artifact and its review team names are published to InReflection.  The process of enriching the artifact through a reflective dialogue between the Reflectors and the Creators is transparent (Criteria here).


Upon recommendation for publication, the submission is assigned a stable URL and indexed. Artifacts not recommended for publication remain visible with the reflective dialogue unless requested otherwise by the creator.